Posts

Long Long Ago…

Image
C. 2008 Well maybe not “long long ago”. To be real…September 17, 2014 was my last post to this blog. Almost a decade. Back then, bloggin’ was somewhat new, at least to me, having started in 2011. Writing thoughts to anonymous readers was a way to crystallize the research and application of what I’ve developed over my many years in the design and construction industry. Much of this thinkery was applied to projects that achieved great success, beyond my expectations. Many fell flat on their face, providing insult to my ego, a loss of credibility to some, humility, doubt in my mind. What the hell…let’s tweak it and try again! And the outcomes always got better in direct proportion to my learning from both success and failure. On that note, the note of courage to try again, I have a future post coming. The story of a major government project, millions of dollars, a third-party critique of the project approach, an empty office occupied by only me and a government PM (who had about 20 bosses...

DBIA's 10 BP's in 10 Post (#2)

Image
NREL's First DB Project If you missed my discussion on DBIA Best Practice #1 and the introduction of this series, now is the time to review . Moving on to BP#2 An owner should implement a procurement plan that enhances collaboration and other benefits of design-build and is in harmony with the reasons that the owner chose the design-build delivery system. Right off the bat, this practice charges the owner with fostering a procurement plan that enhances “collaboration”: a prominent opportunity and result of Design-Build Done Right. However, the beneficial affects of collaboration do not move from opportunity to result without a determined effort on the part of the owner. To pause here, and go deeper into collaboration, consider that this requires the owner, designer and builder to make commitments, and keep them. The owner is, and must be, the guardian of the collaborative effort: because the project owner is uniquely positioned as the default “governor” of th...

Net-Zero Difference Between Winning & Losing

Image
If you are interested in “green” buildings (irrespective of how you define that), and want to change your project’s outcome to achieve your definition of “green”, then you may find this post interesting. If you are interested in “ugly” buildings (however you may define that), and want to create the world’s most “ugly” building, then you too may find this post interesting. In other words: if you are interested in (fill in the blank) buildings, and want to create the most (fill in the blank) building in history, then you should definitely find this post interesting.

DBIA's 10 BPs in 10 Posts (#1)

Image
Practice Makes Perfect Now that the design and construction 'world' is taking in Design-Build Institute of America's ( DBIA ) 10 Best Practices for Design-Build , I want to take time and convince all that this "living" document of practices is, indeed, a sort of magic.  I say 'magic', because to follow these practices is to transform an otherwise adequate outcome into a High  Performance  Outcome … and that is what I'm here to advance. I'm not going to recite the 10 BP's: you can read them for yourselves. What I want to do in this blog-series is share my  experience with  each: gained over the past 15 years, on how I've applied them (before & after their systemization)  and either succeeded or failed with each. In this way I intend to give you, the reader, a practical perspective of each, and how they have accomplished their goal implicit in the document's introduction:

Give Me Liberty, or Give Me Death?

Image
Patrick Henry, 1736-1799 It's seems somewhat just that the defender of liberty spoke his famous words before citizens considering a new convention for government. To borrow from Patrick Henry's inspiration, consider these questions in the context of "conventional" project delivery strategies: What if you could name the bid-price for your next project? What if you could be certain that the price you name satisfies all of your project needs? What if the project you purchased, at the price you named, exceeded all of your expectations? What if all this could be done within a marketplace ready to respond? What if you could do the same when it comes to project delivery and the acquisition of your next project?  This is exactly what the City of Liberty Missouri is doing for their new $65 million wastewater treatment facility and collection/conveyance system improvements. That's right, Liberty!

What's Holding Back "High Performance Green Buildings"?

Image
3 Common Roadblocks to Achieving Project Performance 1- The Project Delivery Model: This is not to say that all three primary Delivery Models can't achieve a "High Performance" result. It's that the risk/cost associated with various Project Delivery Models creates a barrier to High Performance by jeopardizing the project's budget. The proof of this is evident in the inventory of High Performance Green Buildings built over the past several years. They are the exception, not the rule. All things being equal, no owner would avoid the creation of a facility that reduces their energy costs by up to 50%, unless their budget "forbids" it.

Trust, Faith, Collaboration, and Integration: DBIA's 10 Best Practices

Image
"What's right" with our evolving industry? DBIA has just released its 10 Best Practices...a recipe moving forward for true 'integration' and collaboration', and a distinguishing of their individual purpose and practice. How does one build trust? I wrote a blog post about trust a few months back; I believe trust to be an unnatural act past the age of 4 or so. Unfortunately life teaches us this. Trust is built through 'performance'. If a person agrees to do something for another (promise), and in turn satisfies the promise (the results), then trust is planted between the two. If repeated reliably, then trust grows firmly. I believe only people can be trusted. Institutions can only establish a faith in their credo.

Innovative Project Owners Play "Money Ball"

Image
Copying the A's "High Performance Outcome" Recently it seems like all the articles I read on Green and Sustainable Building Projects focus on the innovations of design thinkery  and construction activity . Some of the  Success Stories go into significant detail in explaining the innovative processes or approaches applied. These advancements, of course, are critical to advancing the creation of High Performance Outcomes. It further seems to me that these documented advancements "are heavy" on the Designer/Builder side of the ledger. By this I mean there's more discussion on how the architect, engineers, builders, suppliers, subs, etc. are applying an innovative process or re-inventing an approach that chips away at challenges such as energy performance, schedule length, waste reduction, constructability, and so on.

New Facebook Page & Website

Image
www.designsensespa.com As you regular readers should know, I'm the Principal Consultant for DesignSense-Strategic Project Acquisitions.  DesignSense   provides Construction Project Owners a one-stop source to support their staff and stakeholders in the development, documentation, and implementation of Integrated Project Delivery and Design-Build. And as industry leaders in Alternative Project Delivery, DesignSense guides Private, Public, and Federal projects throughout the United States, using the advanced  3PQ Acquisition & Management System : the  elements of which have been discussed extensively at this blog.

FREE Net-Zero Energy Performance for Buildings

Image
The procurement "lesson-learned"  from the DOE/NREL Research Support Facility project in Golden, Colorado is Net-Zero Energy does not add cost to the project. That's right, DOE didn't pay a penny more for Net-Zero Performance of the 350,000 SF building than set forth in the original budget. Phases 1 and 2 of the RSF Project have now been in operation for more than a year. The energy performance has been verified at Net-Zero and the final cost for the project met the appropriated budget, which did not require a Net-Zero Energy outcome. What caused the FREE upgrade in operational performance was the procurement process used on the project.

Embarrassing "Train Wreck"?

Image
"What the hell happened?" This opinion post began as a comment on LinkedIn: "Design-Build Professionals Group" mixed with reports I've read from ENR ... One "designs" in reaction to a known (or stated) problem, i.e. keep water off my head. One might say the designer is predicting how water is kept off the head (a roof), but the "design" is a reaction to being wet. The "design" reacts to the "problem". Sullivan taught us form "follows" function. "Reaction" is also why owner's "qualify" designers based on experience (are you a good problem-solver?) 

Here's the "Valuable Part" of Best Value

Image
Bid Poker High bid, low bid, right bid: every "Established Solution" has just one cost... Once a "solution" is established within a set of plans & specs, its resulting "cost" is likewise established. Other than human error during the "take off" or applying "proprietary management techniques", the bid-price from all players in a given market-place will be about the same. This is why we dis-trust bids too far outside the median bid-price: "something must be wrong" Contractors buy material, labor, and management for about the same cost in any given market, and as a result of market competition, all have about the same mark-up. Sure, some may have a slight advantage due to expertise, volume, or exclusivity on materials or labor. But those are fleeting in a competitive free market: the law of competition allows everyone to catch everyone .

The Answer to "Calculating Stipends"

Image
If you're a Project Owner, and you have a "design-build acquisition methodology" that excites the market place and meets all of your "Project Outcome" needs, don't waste your time reading this post. Otherwise, here is the answer to the question, "How much in stipends should I pay the design-build competitors?" The context for this discussion is a  Fixed Price / Variable Solution  competition process using a performance-based design-build RFP Convention that includes a Problem-Based Contract . The question becomes, "What  opinions  do I need to see, and what are those opinions  worth ?" Design worth considering is design worth paying for. A proposed design solution that informs the owner during the Evaluation & Selection stage of an acquisition process can be the difference between excellence and disappointment. So, getting "valuable" proposed strategies and/or solutions (an opinionated answer) that satisfy your "...

How Would Steve Jobs Have Delivered "Green Buildings"

Image
Question for an owner beginning a new construction project, "Are you purchasing a Service or a Product?" I think this is an interesting question for owners to ponder as they begin another "Project Acquisition Process"; Service or Product? The former is, to a degree, well mapped and established. There are variations to the Delivery Model (Design-Bid-Build vs. IPD or Design-Build) used by owners. But within those various models, there is a somewhat established process to what and how one purchases services in pursuit of delivering a project; or at least we all accept that there is. How Would Steve Jobs Have Done Green Buildings? Purchasing-processes and management-approaches used by owners when buying 'services' provided by designers and builders is the subject of books, coursework, training, and convention throughout our industry. In simple terms it begins by establishing the 'needs' statement, then it's hire programming services, hire de...

How Do You Stump A Project Owner?

Image
Defining Contractual Scope for Design-Build   One of my favorite quotes comes from Maya Angelou: “ We do what we know ”. This definitely holds true for our industry at the outset of a project. 3PQ Film Link; "Satisfying Scope" For most owners, a project’s first step is establishing a budget based on a value-analysis. I use value because it speaks to an owners base business model. If an owner manufactures widgets, the cost of production contributes to the cost of the widget. Once one ascertains the total cost of delivery for each widget (including the acquisition cost of the widget-making-facility), they can in-turn establish a free-market price for said widget. Using this example, what applies to the design & construction industry is the acquisition cost of the manufacturing facility. Since the widget price is set in a free market, the manufacturing facility’s acquisition cost is like wise set (or at least capped). Let’s change the s...

Riddle Me This:

Image
It’s color and goal are lockset at start  But process and flow, tradition in part Panic pros and bank, compared to the “cart” Though known by us all, we tear it apart The answer to this riddle can be found in this: YouTube Documentary: "Achieving Best Value" Over the past few years, I’ve read a number of articles, white papers, and case-studies concerning Net Zero Energy and High Performance Green Buildings. Just about all of them offer design process & construction technology advice, and step-by-step directives to achieve a “Net Zero Energy High Performance Green Building”…wow, that term is a mouth-full. By example, the white paper put out by BD+C ( www.bdcnetwork.com ) entitled “Zero and Net-Zero Energy Buildings + Homes: Eighth in a series of white papers on Green Building Movement” has a sidebar: Step-by-step Design Map to Net-Zero Energy William Maclay, AIA, a principal with Maclay Architects, Waitsfield, Vt., offers this step-by-step ...